The VB-G RAM G Act (Viksit Bharat-Guarantee for Rozgar and Ajeevika Mission - Gramin) of 2025 has become the center of a major legal and political firestorm in India. As it officially replaces the two-decade-old MGNREGA, a Public Interest Litigation (PIL) filed in the Madras High Court today, February 15, 2026, has brought the law's most controversial provisions under judicial scrutiny.The Core of the Dispute: Reform or Rollback?
The lawsuit challenges eight specific provisions of the new Act, with petitioners arguing that the law dismantles the "right to work" and replaces it with a "discretionary dole."
1. The Funding Shift (60:40 Split)
Under the original MGNREGA, the Central Government funded 100% of unskilled wages.
The New Law: The Centre now provides only 60% of the total funds, leaving States to cover the remaining 40%.
The Lawsuit's Argument: Petitioners claim this places a "catastrophic" financial burden on poorer states, which may lead them to stop registering worker demand to save costs.
2. The 60-Day "Blackout" Period
The Act introduces a mandatory pause in public works for up to 60 days during peak sowing and harvesting seasons.
The Government’s View: This ensures farmers have enough labor and prevents artificial wage inflation during critical agricultural windows.
The Lawsuit's Argument: Critics argue this hurts the most vulnerable landless laborers who may not find private work during these periods or may be underpaid, stripping them of their safety net when they need it most.
3. Supply-Driven vs. Demand-Driven
The most significant shift is the move toward a "Normative Allocation" model.
Instead of being purely demand-driven (where work is provided whenever a worker asks), the Centre will now determine state-wise funding based on "objective parameters" and "notified rural areas."
The Legal Challenge: The PIL argues this violates the 73rd Constitutional Amendment by stripping Gram Panchayats of their autonomy to plan and execute works based on local needs.
The Government's Defense
Union Agriculture Minister Shivraj Singh Chouhan has defended the Act as a "modern statutory framework" for a "Viksit Bharat" (Developed India). The government argues that:
Increased Days: Raising the guarantee to 125 days provides higher income security.
Productive Assets: The focus shifts from "low-utility" works to "durable assets" like water security and climate-resilient infrastructure.
Efficiency: Weekly wage payments and AI-driven monitoring will eliminate the corruption that plagued the old system.
The Madras High Court is expected to hear the preliminary arguments later this week, a case that will likely determine the future of rural livelihoods for over 120 million workers across India.
Op-Ed: The Gendered Cost of Progress – How India’s New VB-G RAM G Act Impacts Rural Women
For nearly two decades, MGNREGA served as more than just a job scheme; it was a silent revolution for rural Indian women. By providing local, low-barrier work with equal pay, it became the largest employer of women in the world. However, as the Viksit Bharat-Guarantee for Rozgar and Ajeevika Mission - Gramin (VB-G RAM G) Act of 2025 replaces this legacy, the shift from a "Right-to-Work" to a "Centrally-Planned" model threatens to undo years of financial empowerment for women.
1. The Local Work Trap: Why Distance Matters
Under the old MGNREGA, work was mandated within a 5km radius of the worker’s home. This was crucial for women who juggle domestic chores and childcare.
The New Fear: The VB-G RAM G Act prioritizes "durable asset creation"—such as highways and large-scale water reservoirs—which are often located further away from village centers.
The Impact: If work moves to distant project sites, women’s participation is expected to plummet. For a rural woman, a job 15km away isn't just a commute; it's an impossibility.
2. The 60-Day "Pause Window": A Blow to Independence
One of the most controversial updates is the 60-day mandatory pause during peak agricultural seasons.
The Logic: The government argues this prevents labor shortages on private farms.
The Reality for Women: While men may find work on those private farms, women are often relegated to unpaid family labor or face lower wages in the private sector. The "pause" strips them of the one source of income where they were legally guaranteed equal pay to men.
3. The Biometric Barrier
The new Act leans heavily into AI-driven attendance and biometric authentication to curb corruption.
The Tech Gap: In many rural areas, women have lower rates of digital literacy and less frequent access to updated Aadhaar-linked mobile numbers.
Failure to Launch: Technical glitches—like fading fingerprints from manual labor or poor network connectivity—disproportionately exclude older women from the system, turning a technological safeguard into a tool of exclusion.
Deep Dive: The Technology Requirements of VB-G RAM G
The government’s vision for "Viksit Bharat" relies on a high-tech architecture intended to make the scheme "leak-proof." Here is the breakdown of the new digital requirements:
AI-Enhanced Attendance: Unlike the manual muster rolls of the past, the new system uses the NMMS (National Mobile Monitoring System) with a double-layered AI check. It requires two time-stamped, geo-tagged photos of workers daily to prove they are physically on-site.
Aadhaar-Based Payment System (ABPS): Payments are now strictly through ABPS. By April 2025, over 1.2 crore job cards were deleted during the "cleaning" of the database to prepare for the new Act.
Gati Shakti Integration: Project planning is no longer just a village-level discussion. All "VB-G RAM G" projects must be uploaded to the PM Gati Shakti portal to ensure they align with national infrastructure goals.
Weekly Biometric Payouts: To improve worker security, the Act mandates weekly wage payments, with a maximum limit of 14 days, facilitated through real-time digital tracking.
The Verdict: While the increase to 125 days of work looks good on paper, the transition from a demand-driven right to a supply-driven government mission creates a "digital gatekeeper" that many of India’s most vulnerable workers may not be able to pass.
Note: News moves fast. While this summary was accurate at the time of writing, events may have progressed since publication.
Comments
Post a Comment